Saturday, August 30, 2014

Phelps background connected to Storyville Coffee continued,

published at
 
Update on Paul Tripp & The BOAA
As we have shared before, Paul Tripp recently resigned his membership from our Board of Advisors and Accountability. To the best of our knowledge at the time, this was due to his intent in helping Mars Hill as a paid consultant.
 
Paul later released a statement, adding additional comments that he did not believe the structure of the Board that he joined was healthy, and that we should add accountability from local members of the church. Paul’s concerns were not made known to the Board as a whole before he resigned; however, we agree there is wisdom in adding local members to this board and we were already in the process of doing just that.
 
We have now become aware of new comments and concerns that Paul Tripp has voiced about Pastor Mark and Pastor Sutton within the last week to a small group of current elders at Mars Hill. These elders then posted these comments as a letter in an unsecure place, and the letter has since been posted online by various critics and media sources.
 
Paul Tripp’s comments to our elders were never made directly to the Board of Advisors and Accountability, as we have minutes of these meetings. We are deeply disappointed that Paul did not bring these concerns to our full Board or to the Executive Elders directly.
 
The concerns brought forth by these elders and the comments from Paul Tripp have been heard and are being taken seriously. Their letter, as with past letters voicing accusations toward Pastor Mark, will be processed in accordance with our bylaws. This means the accusations will be thoroughly examined and a report issued when the review is complete.
 
As for the Board of Advisors and Accountability we are pleased to announce that the vacancies created on the Board were filled with local members of our church who meet the ECFA guidelines for independence. Pastor Matt Rogers is a local Seattle business leader and has been serving as a volunteer elder at Mars Hill Church Bellevue. He will also serve as the Chairman of the Board of Elders which will provide increased accountability in areas of financial responsibility, staff and elder transitions and church culture. The other vacancy on the BOAA has been filled by John Phelps. John is a successful businessman and longtime member of Mars Hill. We are excited for these men to provide local perspective and accountability on our Board.

John Phelps may or may not be the same as Jon Phelps, but the Phelps is described as a longtime member of Mars Hill.  Sources for Wenatchee The Hatchet have not been able to verify that Phelps has any account on The City, but a membership contract was an option without City membership for more than half the history of Mars Hill.  It's possible that at one point Phelps had a profile on The City but doesn't have one now.  In any event, since membership at Mars Hill Church so frequently tends to include City membership/access (and the revocation of this privilege was one of the signature disciplinary elements in the Andrew Lamb case) it would be normative to anticipate City access ... but, moving along.

Thanks to some alert readership, and in light of a report that Jon Phelps has been reportedly added as a member of the Mars Hill Board of Advisors and Accountability, here are a few extra bits of coverage of Storyville Coffee and associated companies.


http://seattle.eater.com/archives/2013/09/19/storyvilles-flyboy-to-challenge-starbucks.php
September 19, 2013
Storyville is run by founder Jon Phelps and his co-presidents Jamie Munson (a youthful former executive pastor of Mars Hill Church, currently a writer and motivational speaker) and Kris Rosentrater, who's been running the day-to-day roasting operation on Bainbridge


http://theseattlecoffeeproject.wordpress.com/2013/11/07/life-as-story-storyville/
... Storyville is the product of Jon Phelps, Jamie Munson, and Kris Rosentrater. The business began as a mail-based bean retailer. The Bainbridge roasting facility offered one signature blend called Prologue with a decaf alternative, appropriately called Epilogue.
...
The plane in that logo has a story as well.  You can see it’s real life inspiration in a photomontage against the wall: a bright shiny Douglas D-3. The Barista tells me the plane actually belongs to owner Jon Phelps.  This machine has shown up in Phelp’s other creative and business pursuits: the name of his musical project, the DC3 Orchestra, and the logo for Full Sail University, which he was founder of.  The Douglas D-3 was an early commercial passenger aircraft, one of the planes that made air travel accessible to the public. A vehicle that allowed people to travel to new places, have new adventures, and create new stories.

You also get a glimpse of Storyville’s own backstory when walking in to the cafĂ©. On the wall, in large silver letters, is a quote from Gary Phelps, Jon Phelp’s son. Gary has Down’s Syndrome, and when friends discovered they were expecting a Down’s Syndrome baby, they met with the Phelp family to help them understand what to expect. Jon turned the question over to his son, asking him what it was like, having Down’s. Gary thought for a moment then said, “Love everybody, never ever hurt anybody.”

The DC-3 is to be expected, and while what happened to DC-3 Entertainment (this, perhaps?) is a bit of a mystery perhaps some readers can find things out about that.  saf

Some local Queen Anne coverage from February 2014
http://queenannenews55.1upprelaunch.com/main.asp?SectionID=26&SubSectionID=337&ArticleID=35257
...
Not everyone has welcomed Storyville with open arms, though. An October 2013 article in The Stranger proposed the coffee company’s relationship to Mars Hill Church. The church and its head pastor, Mark Driscoll, have long been connected with messages of misogyny and homophobia. Munson was a former executive pastor at Mars Hill, the article states.

A follow-up article shows a since-removed post on the Mars Hill site that said, “God has used Storyville Coffee to bless Mars Hill Downtown. Since the Downtown campus has been planted, Storyville has donated tens of thousands of dollars worth of coffee, supplies and equipment.”
Munson denies any connection to Mars Hill and says the shops do not donate anything to the church. Lund has had customers come in and ask about it, but it’s a quick conversation when she explains they have no affiliation, she said.

“It’s a little unfair,” Munson said about the presumed connection. “But it hasn’t shut us down.”
Last week, the Queen Anne Moms and Dads group were circulating emails about the possible Mars Hill connection. Moderator Jill Gallagher said she doesn’t believe in what Mars Hill stands for and won’t patronize a company affiliated with them.

It might, perhaps, have been a little unfair but as Wenatchee The Hatchet documented in two places, there were reasons to believe that in spite of a lack of any formal connections between Storyville and Mars Hill Church Jamie Munson was still listed as a pastor for those who had access to The City.

See an old post from October 2013
http://wenatcheethehatchet.blogspot.com/2013/10/where-are-they-now-update-2-jamie.html

and more recently
June 9, 2014, replete with a redacted screen capture of what was then Munson's current (to the day) profile on The City

http://wenatcheethehatchet.blogspot.com/2014/06/jamie-munsons-role-within-mars-hill.html

By that time, however, Munson was not at Storyville, was he? Precisely when Munson stepped out would be difficult to pin down but he was gone by then.
http://wenatcheethehatchet.blogspot.com/2014/06/jamie-munson-now-lists-himself-as.html

Rosentrater was gone by then, too. 

Perhaps more salient, there was another company that may provide a clue as to when the transition happened, perhaps. 

http://www.bainbridgereview.com/business/134131098.html
https://opencorporates.com/officers/81635026

JONATHAN PHELPS
Company    inactive
SEATTLE QUEEN ANNE, LLC
Name
JONATHAN PHELPS
Position
member

It isn't described as currently inactive but Munson's departure from Storyville was confirmed at least by way of a LinkedIn adjustment.

http://www.sos.wa.gov/corps/search_detail.aspx?ubi=603183232
SEATTLE QUEEN ANNE, LLC
UBI Number             603183232
Category               LLC
Active/Inactive        Active
State Of Incorporation WA
WA Filing Date         02/21/2012
Expiration Date        02/28/2015
Inactive Date 
Duration Perpetual

Agent Name
CT CORPORATION SYSTEM 
505 UNION AVE, SE STE120
OLYMPIA WA 98501 

Manager
MUNSON , JAMIE
9459 COPPERTOP LOOP NE
SEATTLE , WA 98110 

Manager
THOMPSON , BRAD
9459 COPPERTOP LOOP NE
SEATTLE , WA 98110 

Member, Manager
PHELPS , JONATHAN
9459 COPPERTOP LOOP NE
SEATTLE , WA 98110 

Manager
ROSENTRATER , KRIS
9459 COPPERTOP LOOP NE
SEATTLE , WA 98110 

POSTSCRIPT
this was conveyed to Wenatchee The Hatchet just recently
http://www.northlandchurch.net/blogs/dc3o_leading_worship_at_northland_this_weekend/

http://www.stumptownblogger.com/2009/06/a-classic-bird-from-ty-rogoway-photography.html

http://www.dc3orchestra.com/


3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Storyville coffee is the same business model as Mars Hill. The executives, Jon, Jamie and Kris use the lower level staff as their new congregation. They claim to support Human Trafficking causes as the pillar of the business strategy but refuse to post any annual list of who they donate to, other than themselves. There is nothing to validate anything they stand for. I've talked to some employees in the main outlet at Pike Street in Seattle. They aren't able to provide, or even point to a list either. They conveniently hide all information from lower level employees as well. See if you can locate a Mission Statement, or an About, or History information. They won't provide that either. I think the Love Everybody is a total ruse - what a better way to distance oneself in the mindset of Mars Hill, than to create a motto as opposite as possible so no one could 'possibly', even remotely think its the same business model. The business never changed. The lower level staff is just their new congregation feeding resources, support and generating finances to send up the ladder. And Wow - you should pick away at how many execs there are for such a tiny organization of only a couple of stores. There are a Lot! Phelps Full Sail University has been stung several times, by Rachael Maddow, NBC Investigative Reports (apr 2019) as well as the New York Times for scamming U.S. Veterans into loans they cannot pay back. Full Sail has a 100% Acceptance rate ($$) with a 34% graduation rate. UGH! Love Everybody, just not Veterans. And I've heard, they don't like cripples in wheelchairs either. Their corp folks work out of 2 locations, each up a stair case and neither with elevator access. Ouch!! Go into any store and ask. The entire business is built on deception and lies. Still a pack of cruel inhuman people.

Wenatchee the Hatchet said...

Are you sure that's an up to date take on the company, in terms of officers?

According to Munson he hasn't been a co-president of Storyville since 2014. Munson is owner of Simply Seattle these days and has been avoiding any mention of Mars Hill anything even though for a good twenty year period the only jobs he ever had were through Mars Hill.
https://www.linkedin.com/in/jamiemunson

Now I'm of a conviction that Jamie became a pastor strictly through the favor of a good old boy network by dint of being mini-Mark. But ... he seems to be out of ministry lately, which can probably only be a good thing.

as currently listed only Jon and Esther Phelps are listed as officers of the corporation with Jeff Smyth as registered agant.

https://ccfs.sos.wa.gov/#/BusinessSearch/BusinessInformation

Registered Agent Name:JEFF SMYTH
Street Address:1325 4TH AVE STE 940, SEATTLE, WA, 98101-2509, UNITED STATES

GOVERNOR INDIVIDUAL ESTHER PHELPS
GOVERNOR INDIVIDUAL JON PHELPS

I've seen a little of the public criticism of the privately owned college systems

Anonymous said...

I will correct myself following up on your notation and speaking with one of the current Storyville barista's. According to the front line staff, Jamie left Storyville in the Spring of 2019. Because of the tight Mars Hill affiliation he is making all efforts to distance himself as much as possible - understandably so.
While the Love Everybody slogan is also a very clever ruse in attempt to also distance themselves in the public mindset as far away as possible as well. They just don't love US Veterans or people in wheelchairs who are unable to visit, or work, at their headquarter offices, reachable only by a long staircase with no elevator access. Top Floor, Penthouse Suite, 600 Stewart Street Seattle WA 98101.
Following the same Mars Hill avoidance model, they refuse to validate any data regarding human trafficking donations - even to their internal staff. Go into any retail outlet and ask any barista if they have ever seen a printed list of where they have donated funds. I have asked, several times. It's a unified,'No'. It a complete marketing 'feel good' deception. They don't like to be asked about it either to the point where the notation of Human Trafficking was removed from all their packaging at the end of 2019 because too many people were asking for validation of donations.
Another marketing deception is the self promoting rating in all their literature and web site as the "#1 Roaster in America" by Wine Enthusiast Magazine which comes from Joseph Phelps, of Joseph Phelps Vineyards Napa Valley, CA. A relative of Jon Phelps. Why else would a California wine magazine be rating a Seattle coffee roaster? (note: Joseph died in 2015)
Storyville President,'Melanie'(Parks) also denies any affiliation to Mars Hill in social media responses even though Jon Phelps sat on the Board of Advisory and Accountability, and Jamie Munson wrote the church bylaws in 2007 - one year after Storyville opened.
In 2014, after All the Seattle retail outlets opened, the internal Mars Hill bulletin board proudly posted a Thank You to Storyville for coffee, supplies and thousands of dollars in donations.
The Mars Hill business model still exists today. Denial, Deception and Zero transparency.