Saturday, December 13, 2025

When arts critics have no real gatekeeping power they are nothing more than super-consumers--thoughts on reading Freddie deBoer's hatred of Stranger Things and the decline of the negative review

It's been a while since I've blogged about anything written by Freddie deBoer, whose Substack I do read semi-regularly. Since some of his writing intersects with thoughts I've been having about the state of criticism and laments about the state of the arts and the state of criticism I'm goingto go a bit long-form this weekend.

Fix Your Family Systems: Breaking Toxic Patterns Through Biblical Wisdom is here, from the guy who said back in 1998 that he was a confrontational guy and not some pansy-ass therapist

https://www.motherjones.com/politics/1998/07/generation/

Politics

July/August 1998 Issue

GENERATION

A look inside fundamentalism’s answer to MTV: the postmodern church.

...

By setting themselves up against their elders, postmoderns are ingeniously adding an anti-establishment spirit to their movement. “I really preach; it’s not just three points to a better self-esteem,” Driscoll says. “Megachurches have perfect services with perfect lighting. We’re a friggin’ mess.” Driscoll delivers his sermons largely off-the- cuff, and refuses to follow a point-by-point outline like most pastors at megachurches do. “I’m very confrontational,” he says, “not some pansy-ass therapist.”

...

“Some of us haven’t given ourselves over to the American Dream yet,” Driscoll says into the microphone. “How do we make sure we don’t become victims of what harmed us— parents who weren’t around because they were too busy making money so we could go on vacations and look like a family?” The phones are dead.

...

A lot can change in 27 years.