Monday, June 04, 2012

Internet Monk: Flying through the flame of creativity

http://www.internetmonk.com/archive/flying-through-the-flame-of-creativity

Jeff Dunn posted a lecture transcript of a talk given by Dr. Peter Van Lorn about art and creativity.  Van Lorn opened with the warning that he was going to try to dissuade you from becoming an artist. He said that if he could not dissuade people from a life spent in the arts he could at least warn them of what such a life would entail.

Van Lorn went on to explain that a life in the arts is a vocation and not necessarily a career. He noted that creativity is both a grace and a curse.  I suppopse it could be said to be so but I am not quite sure I agree.  I am going to pick something that expresses this concept, as I understand it in Van Lorn's lecture in less spiritual and in more economic terms.

Creativity and the impulse to create is something that can arguably be found in every human. How this impulse to create emerges and is executed varies drastically from person to person.  A parent brainstorming creative ways to cook and plan meals around a child's food allergies is exercising a fantastic level of creativity that may not be appreciated as "art".  Yet it is both an art and a science.  The modern era has separated the professional from the amateur in ways that are not always good.  Different musicians in the 20th century had different thoughts about the gap between the professional musician and the amateur.  Shostakovich discouraged one of his wives from doing too much music because he felt it was best left to professionals.  Hindemith, by contrast, wrote an entire string quartet to play with his wife Gertrud because she decided to take up the cello.  Bach legendarily wrote and dedicated any number of works to his wife and children. Of course Bach was a professional musician the likes of which we may never see again but he clearly had no problem writing for both professionals and amateurs.

But creativity as a grace and a curse seems a bit extreme to me in terms of expression.  What it has in poetry it lacks, I humbly suggest, in a certain precision. Pursuing creativity in the arts has what may be called a "curse" but also what may be called opportunity costs.  Pursuing a life in the arts will often mean not pursuing a life in other things.  Pursuing a life in other things, which so very many people do, often entails not truly pursuing activity in the arts.  I have met a few people who have devoted themselves to marriage and parenting and these are wonderful vocations. These vocations often, however, preclude a pursuit of the arts.  More accurately, if you have a good relationship with your spouse and children and are not already in the arts vocationally then you may benefit from spending more time with your spouse and raising your children than trying to immerse yourself in the arts too far and too much.

A life in the arts is not really a lonely life as such (though it can be) but it is a life in which you are at times forced to confront the reality of the opportunity costs you have to deal with.  I have noticed this in my absence of a dating life (though chronic underemployment plays a substantial role there, too).

Van Lorn attributes Bach's generally joyful music to the external circumstance of the Christian faith.  Musicologists have not always been eager to stress Bach's interest in Christian doctrine or practice.  As Hindemith noted in his short lecture on Bach the fact that only four of Bach's twenty children survived into adulthood and only three of those kept what we would now call sanity; and given that Bach's first wife died it would be difficult to say that Bach's life was particularly joyful in circumstances.  There was a lot of success in Bach's life but there was also plenty of suffering.   I don't think a parent could just shake off the loss of sixteen children and a wife.

I do, however, agree with Van Lorn's suggestion, which he does not spell out in philosophical terms as such, that the artist has a vocation in which art can become a kind of meta-teleological study.  If there any composer of whom we may propose that this took the form of a conscious vocation J. S. Bach might be the best candidate in Western music.

The observation that nothing is less real than realism may be worth discussing at some length.  I have been writing about the DC animated universe fashioned by Paul Dini, Bruce Timm, Allen Burnett, Dwayne McDuffie and others over at Mockingbird for a bit more than a year.  Eve Tushnet remarked that "realism" is a term that presupposes one's view of the world is realistic and that the rest of us must settle for genre. Critics who lament the prevalence of superhero films and like more "realistic" stories don't always seem to register that realistic stories are not always realistic.  The tropes of the superhero story are no less etched in stone than those of the romantic comedy.  I would venture to say that it makes more sense why Commissioner Gordon doesn't just arrest Bruce Wayne several weeks after Batman begins his war on crime than to explain why Kate Hudson or Meg Ryan end up with the men they end up with by the end of their films.  A guy who dresses like a bat and beats the crap out of people obviously has emotional issues, right?  Mike Nelson of Mystery Science Theater 3000 once observed that if actions X, Y and Z are depicted by Harry Connick Jr. toward a woman in a film that film is a thriller or a horror.  If the same actions are depicted as being done by a woman who is played by Meg Ryan it's considered cute and we're supposed to root for her.

I have often heard it said that the path of the artist is to defy convention and question things and discover the truth.  Artists don't really do this so much, do they?  I mean if it's true that artists are supposed to question the conventions of society why are there so many cliches?  The line between art and commerce has never been as clear-cut as ideologues and idealists would like.  It's true that boy bands tend to be lame and that boy bands tend to be silly, ephemeral assemblages of young guys who want to be celebrities.  Sure, sure, I know ... but didn't the Beatles basically start out as a boy band that eventually transcended the limitations of their idiom?  Weren't they mop tops until George Martin and Brian Epstein and others pushed the Fab Four to be more than they were content to be up to that point in their career?

When I was in high school (how long ago that seems to me now!) I was in art classes.  This was twenty years and two major eye surgeries ago. I drew inspiration from a combination of Salvador Dali's general approach to surrealism and Rembrandt's approach to light and color.  Eventually I'd take an interest in the photography of Margaret Bourke-White and Richard Avedon and, of course, I never really completely lost my interest in comics and was a Bill Watterson fan.  Other students saw some of the work I did and asked me, "So, like, do you drop acid?"

"No." I replied.

"Do you get high?"  The student would ask.

"No."

"You don't do mushrooms or smoke weed?" asked the fellow student, still unsure if I was serious or not.

"No, I don't do any of that stuff." I replied.

"So how do you come up with your ideas?" the student asked without further delay.

"I think them up.  I juse use the brain I have and think of stuff and if I like an idea I go with it."

There was a pregnant pause of about a second and a half and the fellow student said, "Wow, that's messed up."..

That has intrigued me for twenty some years.  It's messed up that I could come up with ideas as an artist without resorting to any drugs of any kind?  It's messed up that I didn't use drugs to create an altered state of mine to come up with surrealistic pictures?  I would think that an artist would want to rely as little as possible on things that alter brain chemistry.  It may be true that drugs eliminate the inhibitions people have about coming up with ideas and that the suspension of inhibitions and self-editing tend toward creativity.

But a balanced approach to artistic activity is a constant synergistic relationship between brainstorming and revision and rejection and extrapolation.  The medievals and ancients were probably far more right than Romantics and some moderns in considering music as an applied science and not merely an art.  I would suggest here that failing to see the arts as applied science at level has two significant costs.

The first cost is that separating any sense of science from aesthetics means that aesthetics becomes arbitrary by necessity. The benefit of such a divorce is that anything goes in theory but the sheer limitations of physics and the extent of the practical has physically limited the arts in ways that I would consider beneficial.  Some of the most beautiful music ever written has been unaccompanied choral music and if you ever want to find out what the most draconian limitations on the musically practical are attempt to write even some basic chorales for unaccompanied chorus.  Either you will eventually discover why Stravinsky said he was most free when he worked within stringent limitations or you'll give up in a furious fit of frustration. If you fail to grasp the connection between the conceptual and the actual then you lose a beautiful way of seeing how and why art (whether commercial or non-commercial) can have a real world connection to living people. That is the practical point.

The second cost of failing to see the arts as applied science is to live life imagining that the utility of art is not an issue because art and science are separated by a breach that should not be crossed.  This seems like a recent and bad innovation.  By "recent" I mean in the last two centuries and I have already intimated as to why I think it is a bad one. I believe the more we study the human mind, cognitive development, social patterns, and the history of music the more we may continue to discover that all of the arts depend on a process of associative memory.  It is known that beauty is in the eye of the beholder but even a blind person can grasp that something is beautiful to taste, touch, hear and smell.  We can assume, as some do, that standards of beauty are culturally defined and that culture is just wrong.

The more research gets done into the the sciences of biology and health the less certain I think this claim can be.  That societies discriminate against those who are considered less beautiful is an injustice but the injustice may not prove that those who are not considered beautiful are beautiful simply because we are reflexively responding to an injustice.  The ugly man does not become less ugly because he is not favored as much as the handsome man.  After all, charm is deceptive and beauty is fleeting but a woman who fears the Lord will be praised. Kindness makes a man attractive.  The ancients understood more readily than we that beauty does not last forever.  After all, they had to deal with much higher infant mortality rates and with the reality of dying sooner than us during many periods of human history.

What Van Lorn seems to call the curse side of the arts I don't agree with unless I take it as circumlocution for other concerns. In many cases people say that art is predicated upon talent.  I have met people who say that talent and quality in the arts is arbitrary and subjective whereas skill can be objectively measured or quantified.  This isn't really the case.  You can objectively establish whether this or that guitarist can play something faster than another but not establish whether or not that is a task worth doing.  Frank Zappa once remarked of John McLaughin that you'd have to be a moron not to appreciate his technique but that he didn't see the aesthetic value of making the guitar sound like a machine gun.  I'm inclined to agree with Zappa's sentiment and believed that McLaughlin's best work was with Miles Davis.  It definitely wasn't McLaughlin's tedious guitar concerto, I'm sorry to say.

While the old adage has it that beauty is in the eye of the beholder the more we learn about cognitive processes and social patterns the more it seems this old proverb is more accurately rendered now as saying "beauty is in the mind of the beholder."  Yet beauty is not just in the mind of the beholder but also within what the  beholder beholds.  Controversially this plays itself out in evolutionary psychologists and others proposing that what is considered sexually desirable has a basis not merely in cultural assumptions about beauty but in some actual physiological realities about the human body and its perception that may turn out to transcend cultural variables.  Some cultures prize bigger women over skinny women but marks of financial and physical stability can remain steady.  Closer adherence to the Golden ratio and to a higher degree of body symmetry can be considered indicators of health and beauty alike among men and women.  Does this seem like something culturally conditioned?  It doesn't seem likely.  It is true there are many unrealistic expectations put forth about beauty and status but it would be as mistaken to assume these are not based in some limited way on physics and biology as it would be to assume it is all culture.

The trouble is that the beholder is plural as well as singular and that the plurality and singularity invariably inform each other.  We know this because cults of beauty exist.  Some people prize Marilyn Monroe, others prize Audrey Hepburn. Others prize Julie Newmar.  Others prize James Dean.  Others prize Brad Pitt or early career Marlon Brando (as opposed to old fat Marlon Brando).  Elizabeth Taylor, anyone? I trust the point gets across.

There is a long history of Christians having a suspicion of the arts.  Early Christians often associated the arts with sexual immorality.  Acting was a terrible profession.  Even the ancient Greeks made a distinction between music as a philosophical or abstract enterprise of the mind and the practical musician, the theoritician could be held in high esteem while the actual performers were considered disreputable. I think it was Guido d'Arezzo who declared that singers were the silliest people on the planet.  He invented the solfeggio system of score-reading because he got sick of stupid and lazy singers not coming in on time and getting notes wrong during performances.  Jokes about the stupidity and horniness of tenors and sopranos have not abated over millenia, have they? Bach got embroiled in controversies over allegations that musicians were basically immoral and stupid sorts.  Puritans had a few words of warning about the arts.  The response by artists of various sorts has been, in my estimation, comparably stupid.

If Christian moralists object to this or that in the arts then artists do themselves and the arts no favors by pretending that the role of the artist is to question the mores and conventions of society.  This pretends to an elevated status the arts have never consistently had.  I give you boy bands.  Preted that that is commerce and not art all you want but the boy band has a song that uses the same major and minor chords and melodic turns you may hear in other more "legitimate" styles of music.  Attempting to differentiate between the "high" and the "low" is a cultural game that I propose may fail on further analysis.  The gap between one style and another is in the mind and the conceptual framework through which we perceive something not merely as music but as an expression of culture.  I'll risk a simplification and put it this way, the gap between blues and country as folk music and popular music wasn't so big in the first half of the twentieth century as it became in the decades after which the commercial recording industry realized they could sell millions of records  if they catered to and defined markets.  Now "new country" just sounds like "old rock" to me.  Sometimes I'm in the mood for that but it's not often and I admit it.

In other words if artists are so important to questioning everything in society why have we had so many millenia of the same stuff getting done over and over again?  Why so many love songs?  Why so many cliches in music?  Why so many stories of starcrossed lovers and corrupt kings? How on earth did Joseph Campbell ever manage to propose the hero's journey if artists were really shaking things up? Even the indie scene is full of its own cliches.  The avant garde ends up sounding the same after a while.  I've tried listening to Elliott Carter and he's not quite my thing.  Boulez is a fantastic conductor but his original compositions have never really interested me.  Edgar Varese has written some fantastic stuff.  Stockhausen has a couple of nice things but in a way these are all people who are spinning out new variations of things that were started by Stravinsky or Schoenberg.  Nobody creates in a vacuum, everyone creates in the context of a shared social life, even the most hermitly hermit around. It was in exile on the island of Patmos that John the Revelator wrote the Apocalypse, the book that deals with the end of what we might lazily called space and time and physical matter as people had been used to knowing those things.

I've rambled on these subjects often enough.  I would agree with Van Lorn that unless you're willing to shoulder the opportunity costs you probably don't want to pursue a life in the arts.  On the other hand there's no reason you can't make the arts a hobby.


No comments: