Thursday, June 07, 2012

HT Pilgrim comment at Phoenix Preacher: James MacDonald's double standards on ministry criticism

http://phoenixpreacher.net/?p=12499#comment-105525

http://bloodstainedink.wordpress.com/2012/06/02/harvest-bible-chapel-these-are-not-the-droids-youre-looking-for/

It's not as cool a title for a blog post as a reference to "These are not the droids you're looking for."  I know.

The post speaks well enough for itself that I'm just linking to it.

I will add this, the problem with reasoning that only those invested monetarily and particpationally in a ministry criticizing a pastoral decision or church direction is that even if you do that and it somehow qualifies you to make a criticism or voice a concern the simple act of doing that can get you fired and declared unfit to say anything.

Go read Joyful Exiles for a bit if you want an in depth case study.  MacDonald's case falls apart not just on the basis of the two specious levels of argument but also because there's a third, who's to say that even if a critic did things MacDonald's way he'd pay any attention to them any more than Driscoll paid attention to concerns about Article VIII?

No comments: