Thursday, March 01, 2012

Robert Cargill posts culminate in "On Being Wrong as a Scholar"

http://robertcargill.com/2012/02/28/on-absaloms-tomb-in-jerusalem-and-nephesh-monument-iconography/
http://robertcargill.com/2012/03/01/antonio-lombatti-presents-evidence-that-the-fish-on-tabor-and-jacobovicis-jonah-ossuary-is-actually-an-amphora/
http://robertcargill.com/2012/03/01/on-being-wrong-as-a-scholar/

All three links are conveniently back to back posts but I link to them all separately so you can see this quick sequence of posts and how Cargill's post "On Being Wrong as a Scholar" reads within the blogging context of what Cargill wrote earlier.

I might only add, not as a professional scholar but as someone who studied journalism that retractions and new statements indicating you changed your mind also help.  A pet peeve of mine over the last fifteen years has been that I come across people who will argue ardently for position A.  Then at some point they change their mind and then argue for position B as though it were always what they thought.  Or they will pretend they never held to position A or dismissively avoid discussing how they got to position B in terms of evidence for or against.  Or in other cases folks argue for position A when it turns out B has been the reality.  You might be able to guess from this I've seen this a bit, particularly in some church settings. .:) 

So, anyway, some blog entries from Cargill for you to peruse today.

No comments: