Thursday, March 01, 2012

HT Frank Turk The Ruling Elder on Mark Driscoll, the Trinity, and W. G. T. Shedd

http://www.therulingelder.com/2012/02/mark-driscoll-trinity-and-w-g-t-shedd.html?spref=tw

Shedd says that those who make the claim that the attempt to define the relationship between the persons of the Trinity is misguided are not the strongest defenders of the Scriptural doctrine of the Trinity, nor have such men been the most successful in keeping clear of Sabellianism. Mark Driscoll is a man who thinks such definitions are misguided. He was interviewing a man who is a Sabellianist (Sabellius being the founder of Modalism which is the ancient form of the modern Oneness view of the Trinity). And guess what? Driscoll did not show himself to be a strong defender of the Scriptural doctrine of the Trinity! Shedd was right.
 
I'd quote more but I don't feel like it.  I've sometimes wanted to wade into Driscoll and Jakes but I've had other things going on like the continuing search for work and tackling a few free-lance projects this month. Blog entries like the above remind me that there's always someone else better situated to address some things than I often am so now that Elephant Room 2 has come and gone I don't have much to add.  I had thought, naively, Driscoll was actually going to ask the really tough questions but I mistook Driscoll the persona for what Driscoll the man opted to do. Now Driscoll probably knows that the Eastern Orthodox do not hold that the Spirit proceeds from both the Father and the Son and thus wishes to avoid continuing disagreements within Christian thought and practice he doesn't have any time or interest in fielding.  At a purely practical level I can get that.
 
But if he wants the kind of long-term influence he's obviously shooting for he can't keep forestalling these kinds of discussions. Assuring us Jakes is not a modalist has not convinced me Jakes isn't a modalist. Folks can agree with creeds that don't work themselves out in practice or teaching. But as I have plenty of "real world" concerns I leave it to other people to tackle all that stuff at this point. 

No comments: