http://oldlife.org/2012/02/send-this-to-members-of-praise-bands-before-it-is-too-late/
http://forsclavigera.blogspot.com/2012/02/open-letter-to-praise-bands.html
Normally I don't take much interest in the Christian blogging convention of open letters. In many cases open letters in Christian blogs tend to be so rote in their obdurate praise or blame they tend to not be open letters so much as special formalities for previously expressed opinions. In fact I drafted a generic one-size-fits-all "open letter" for Christian bloggers a while back on the critical side a while ago.
http://wenatcheethehatchet.blogspot.com/2011/01/pre-written-all-purpose-open-letter-for.html
But in the case of this particular open letter I agree. I'll even reproduce the bullet points.
1. If we, the congregation, can't hear ourselves, it's not worship.
2. If we, the congregation, can't sing along, it's not worship.
3. If you, the praise band, are the center of attention, it's not worship.
Point 2 was a particularly salient issue in a couple of settings I can recall. I've been in churches where the music was performed well and was memorable and sometimes even good. But the thing was that the songs were not always easy to sing along with and I couldn't hear much beyond the performance of the band. Or in other cases everyone else who had music to read from could sing along to songs that were completely unfamiliar to me. I couldn't work out the text or the melody well enough to sing along. What made the situation worse was that I personally used to jam with the church musician who wrote this music! Nothing personal at all, I always liked this particular musician but there is something to be said for being willing to go for a lower common musical denominator. Even volunteer church musicians who show up for a service and haven't had coffee or gotten quite enough sleep will not always be able to sing along with every new song.
Back when I was at Mars Hill there was a big ruckus years ago because some people complained about a particular band. The complaints were the music was too loud and the music was not to everyone's taste. Leadership circled the wagons. It was strange to hear a pastor rebuke the congregation for the fact that some people expressed what could be legitimate concerns. If the band is too loud and the songs are too hard to sing along with then it's a concert venue and not congregational worship.
Does that seem like a liturgical SLAPS test? Yeah, I know, it does seem that way, but the idea of church musicians should be that they should SERVE THE CONGREGATION, right? If I want to experiment with sharing preludes and fugues for solo guitar during communion or offering when no one is expected to sing along (and my pastors are okay with it) then I'll have fun. But when it's me in the congregation or playing anything else I'm happy to follow the advice of a music teacher who once told me the first rule of making music in the real world is that it can never be too easy.
Neo-Calvinist musical culture has not, in my experience, had any real interest in humbly serving the congregants and has a very ardent interest in performance.
Of course I don't agree that a bulls eye would be doing away with bands altogether. Church fads come and go regarding musical practice. The major/minor key system I've seen some people call "robustly trinitarian" is barely more than three centuries old. At one point castrati were sought after for their voices and women were not necessarily getting any place in public music in the local church. The kinds of arguments I've seen against instruments in public worship from Dabney look more like appeals to tradition of the sort that would make sense coming from Eastern Orthodox defenses of tradition. It makes sense from the perspective of the Eastern Orthodox, but the trouble with a regulative principle or other precept that precludes instruments is that the Psalms instruct us to praise the Lord with instruments. It takes a peculiar application of a concept to insist that actually doing what the Scriptures instruct us to do shouldn't be done. But then since I'm linking to a cheeky allusion to a gentle open letter I'm not going to bore you with more and more in this post.
No comments:
Post a Comment