Also that’s fair enough re McClary—I didn’t read this specific article, but it’s a reasonable argument to make. I generally like her work, and appreciate her tireless trolling of the established academy, which has felled many a musicologist who, whilst attempting to retort angrily to her, revealed himself as an inveterate racist or sexist or homophobe et cetera >.>
Pages
- Home
- a page with an index of tagged posts discussing the history of the former Mars Hill Church
- a page with an index of posts on music and musical analysis--guitar sonatas and contrapuntal music for guitar and other musical stuff
- writings at Mbird on animation, superheroes and other things (nobody cares about Jarvis Pennyworth)
Monday, July 23, 2018
an Ethan Hein post that I wrote about has gone missing, the one about John Cage
Also that’s fair enough re McClary—I didn’t read this specific article, but it’s a reasonable argument to make. I generally like her work, and appreciate her tireless trolling of the established academy, which has felled many a musicologist who, whilst attempting to retort angrily to her, revealed himself as an inveterate racist or sexist or homophobe et cetera >.>
3 comments:
- Ethan Hein said...
-
I took the post down because it's not doing the job I wanted it to do, and it's alienating more people than it's convincing. I'd like to come back to it after I figure out how to articulate my argument better, beyond "Cage sucks." (Which, he does, but I want the blog to be more substantive than that.)
Anyway, I'm happy to continue to discuss it here! I agree with you that the high-low divide doesn't always map onto the white-black divide, but in the context of the United States in the 20th century, it's a reasonable equation to make. American popular music is pretty much coextensive with black music, and "art" music is coextensive with European music, at least until recently. It's true that smart people regard raga and gamelan music as "high," but that's a comparatively recent development. It's also true that Western notions of "high" art come out of German idealism, but German idealism was plenty white supremacist.
Cage did some of his most-quoted writing about how distant his work was from jazz when he was living in downtown New York City in 1961. He was within a stone's throw of the clubs where Miles Davis, John Coltrane, Charles Mingus, Thelonious Monk, Cecil Taylor and Ornette Coleman were all at the peak of their game. To think that that music was too "popular," or not intellectual enough, is so shockingly ignorant that I can't square it with Cage's intellect and eclectic listening. He didn't have to like jazz, but his disdain is unfathomable unless there's a racial component. The class component may have been a bigger factor in his mind, but that's not adequate to fill the gap. I'm not saying that Cage was any more racist than any other typical white person of his generation, but he wasn't less racist either. -
5:32 AM
- Wenatchee the Hatchet said...
-
Fair enough. I've taken down a few posts over the years that had unforeseen consequences.
Taruskin's criticisms of Cage seemed persuasive, though he borrowed the idea of Cage as the apotheosis of Romanticism as an ideological stance from Leonard B. Meyer, I think (Music, the Arts and Ideas, also Style and Idea). Taruskin doesn't really disguise his likes and dislikes even when he thinks he is, and fans of Cage or of New Complexity have little regard for Taruskin as a scholar or historian because of his agendas.
Which has me thinking about how in the case of Cage in particular I've read criticism of him and his work from the left by Maoists (Cornelius Cardew and John Tilbury in their book Stockhausen Serves Imperialism) and by religious right pioneer Francis Schaeffer (The God Who is There). What both sides agreed on about Cage was that his ideas are the sort that sound good presented from a podium about music but that he ideas as things you can lie by, that's another story. Certainly plenty of people wouldn't agree with either Maoism or quasi-theonomistic Presbyterianism but it's interesting that from both these directions the criticism of Cage during his lifetime was "you may be able to make music with these ideas but you can't live by them on a daily basis." Taruskin's variation was to question why Cage might say there's "just enough" suffering in the world and to raise a question about whose suffering that was, if memory serves. It might not, but it sounds like you've got access to Taruskin's writings on Cage already.
I hesitate to regard American popular music as being coextensive with black music ... unless you mean to propose that in a Venn diagram there's so much overlap between the two categories it's relatively safe to describe influences from black music on American popular music. Woody Guthrie or Pete Seeger or Hank Williams Sr. or the Carters and varieties of bluegrass come to mind. Now having mentioned those styles and people I think working class white and black musical traditions have more in common with each other than the highbrow against which they were often set.
Raymond Knapp's monograph on Haydn called Making Light got a little bit into minstrelsy and Broadway musicals as regions of camp that were distinguished by their stances against German idealism. His proposal that these musical traditions have been so defined by the racist element (which he doesn't suggest we ignore) or the queer/camp post-Sontag element (which he proposes is too narrow a conception of musicals and he also proposes that we need to recover a pre-Sontagian possibility of camp). Knapp's proposal was that the baggage about race and sexuality for minstrelsy and musicals can distract us from other elements that could explain the popularity and longevity of this traditions and he proposes that these traditions, alongside operetta of the Offenbach and Gilbert & Sullivan variety, represent a centuries long legacy of popular musical idioms that implicitly and even explicitly set themselves against German idealism.
But he proposed something interesting about what kinds of popular music became credible to scholars. The styles that became grist for scholarship were the kinds of rock and pop music that could, paradoxically, be most readily assimilated into and explicable in terms of German idealism.
https://www.amazon.com/Making-Light-Musical-Shadow-Idealism/dp/0822369508/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1532574816&sr=8-1&keywords=making+light+haydn+camp
It was less about Haydn than I was hoping it would be but Knapp sold me on the proposal that German idealism played a significant role in ignoring Haydn in the wake of Mozart and Beethoven, who fit the heroic mythologies of German idealism better; and in proposing that in Haydn's era his relationship to high and low idioms was ambiguous and that his work can be understood as a type of camp.
-
8:32 PM
- Wenatchee the Hatchet said...
-
(continued)
Knapp's book used to be available on an open library format but that little window has, alas, closed. Since one of my personal composer projects is using Haydn's work as a prototype for a contemporary experiment toward fusions of styles (a la Leo Brouwer's comments about fusion as the movement across genres academics have tended to skip past) I'm naturally interested in scholarly work that attempts to look at how Haydn's intercontinental popularity and influence waned in the wake of German idealism. I didn't know how much of his popularity came because people kept pirate-publishing the scores for his string quartets, for instance. Turns out Haydn was, to put it in modern jargon, one of the more bootlegged composers of his era. Charles Rosen believed that Haydn and Mozart demonstrated that, however rare and miraculous it seemed to him in historical terms, a fusion of high and low was possible. That was, arguably, what Wagner aspired to but he put all his eggs in the opera basket ... but I digress, as I tend to do when Haydn is my topic ... .
Since I'm not a Cage fan if it turns out he had a white supremacist streak it wouldn't break my heart since I only actually enjoy his prepared piano music.
1961 ... not that I have to name the jazz albums in which great musicians participated across color lines ... but it's striking that Cage distanced himself from jazz when he did.
I think you saw the other post I did on Cage and I found the Cardew/Tilbury and Xenakis criticisms of aleatory and Cage to be interesting contemporary reactions. Taruskin's work is interesting but he basically summarized comments that were made by the above-mentioned and by Meyer decades earlier. I happen to AGREE with those complaints. )
The weather's not the most pleasant for the region up here in Seattle so I only feel so inspired to write this week. But thanks for coming by and commenting. I hope it's not too oppressively hot where ever you live. -
8:38 PM