http://www.patheos.com/blogs/warrenthrockmorton/2014/02/20/mark-driscolls-citation-errors-at-a-glance/
The chart is fairly comprehensive, it seems. In seven books published since 2008 Mark Driscoll's work has been shown to have a number of citation problems that Throckmorton categorizes as follows: 1) plagiarism 2) factual error 3) ghostwriting 4) recycling own material. This fourth detail will be lost on non-writers but copyright and licensing restrictions can preclude you from recycling your own work across publishers, or preclude you using already published material in a derivative work. Such restrictions are not unheard of, at all, in publishing agreements. So, yes, it actually is possible to self-plagiarize in this day and age, not just in the time of Vivaldi.
As thorough as the chart is, Throckmorton left out the problematic statements Mark Driscoll made about the Targum Neofiti, a rabbinical commentary on Genesis that Mark Driscoll has claimed, and he has credited Gerry Breshears with discovering this:
1) a Targum that predates Jesus by 2 centuries that
2) shows that pre-Jesus Jews believed God was a trinity
Both of these statements have been so thoroughly debunked by the scholars Scott Bailey, Robert Cargill and Christian Brady you can go look up their rebuttals at your leisure. The reason this particular error is egregious is not simply because Driscoll/Breshears presented doubly wrong information about the dating and content of the Targum, but also because this erroneous material is integrated into both the book and the sermon series Doctrine: What Christians Should Believe. Now here's why it matters.
http://thegospelcoalition.org/blogs/justintaylor/2010/05/06/an-interview-with-mark-driscoll-on-the-book-that-cost-mars-hill-a-thousand-church-members-and-gave-him-an-intestinal-ulcer—and-whether-or-not-the-new-calvinist-coalition-will-hold-together/
... As we expand to more campuses, states, and possibly even nations, I wanted to do all I could to ensure doctrinal fidelity and clarity for our church. As the tree grows and the fruit increases, the roots need to sink deep as well. So, when our attendance was at about six thousand people a few years ago, we did something unprecedented. We canceled out the membership of everyone in our church and I preached the Doctrine series for thirteen weeks. Each sermon was well over an hour and included me answering text-messaged questions from our people.
Those who made it through the entire series were interviewed, and those who evidenced true faith in Christ and signed our membership covenant were installed as new members. We had always had a high bar for membership, but I wanted to raise that bar higher as we pursued our goal of becoming, by God’s grace, a church of fifty thousand. In so doing, we lost about a thousand people, dropped to five thousand total, and missed budget for the first time in our church’s history. We then rebounded over the next few years to ten thousand people a week and as many as thirteen thousand on our peak weekend. We had pruned, which hurt, but then we harvested, which was healing.
How exactly is presenting two easily disproven claims about the Targum Neofiti raising the bar for doctrinal fidelity and clarity? Wouldn't a sermon explaining the development of Trinitarian thought in early Christianity have been possible without leaning on Gerry Breshears' alleged discovery?
Now having a statement made in a sermon series that hasn't been thoroughly fact-checked the week of, okay, that's an understandable mistake that can happen from the pulpit. Such things are unfortunate but to err is human, right. But between that sermon in 2008 and the publication of the book in 2010 why did no one spot in the review/fact-checking process that these claims by Driscoll/Breshears were, at best, speculative and at worst patently wrong? It's not as though Christian Brady hadn't debunked all the points Driscoll tried to make about and with the Targum Neofiti the same year the sermon got preached.
Well, perhaps all that was simply a mistake on the part of Driscoll/Breshears. And Driscoll has noted recently that some mistakes were made and the Trial study guide got pulled. Whoever gets the job of editorial manager will have to oversee fact-checking to make sure these sorts of factual errors don't make it into the finished products. If Warren Throckmorton's chart is an indicator of the books published by Driscoll (with or without Breshears) in the past, there may be a lot to be vigilant about in the fact-checking department. Heidelblog fielded the egregious error of Driscoll/Breshears claiming that Arminius was the son-in-law of Calvin. The problem is not necessarily how many factual errors ended up in the Driscoll books but how utterly wrong those factual errors were and how easily they could have been headed off at the pass before publication.
Peruse the chart Throckmorton has posted as you see fit.
No comments:
Post a Comment