http://www.vergenetwork.org/2012/02/02/obituary-for-the-american-church-mike-breen/
Mike Breen lays out three things he says will cause the death of the American church.
From time to time I will have the people I’m discipling write out their own pastoral obituary. I ask them to write out how our enemy would take them out, rendering them unable to serve their family and communities. As you can imagine, the answers vary, but always serves as a really helpful exercise as they are forced to confront issues of character, etc.
Now last week I did a post looking at some of the things the American church is doing well. Today, let’s do something different. You see, taking the same exercise I’ve used with pastors, for the past year I’ve been thinking how the enemy would/might be trying to take down the American church. Now what I’ve noticed is that the original temptations Jesus faced (which can best be boiled down to Appetite, Affirmation and Ambition) are somehow warped and insinuated into the culture. As each culture is distinct and different, a smart enemy would come at each culture in subtle ways, tempting them in ways they don’t see or expect, and with things that would look different from culture to culture. ...
A culture of CELEBRITY (affirmation)
A culture of CONSUMERISM (appetite)
A culture of COMPETITION (ambition)
These are three interesting things, aren't they? If you disagree you probably won't read on anyway.
Celebrity is probably the first and easiest symptom to observe in the disease:
... I suspect it’s because riven deeply into the American psyche is the desire to be a celebrity. And American pastors are very susceptible to this. Many subtle things happen in people who desire to this kind of celebrity status:
* They can disengage community and isolate themselves, setting themselves up for moral failure.
* They can make decisions that are numbers driven and not always Kingdom driven.
* They can skew to a shallow understanding of the Gospel as opposed to a holistic one that leads people to discipleship.
* They can put the good of their church (their personal Kingdom) over the good of God’s Kingdom.
Celebrity pastors who disengage from community and isolate themselves do set themselves up for moral failure. About this I could say a great deal but I wish merely to note the following--the moral failure a celebrity pastor may become guilty of won't always be about sex. Americans and evangelicals are so used to the sex scandal that when a controversy DOESN'T INVOLVE a sex scandal we breath a sigh of relief and say, "Oh, well, at least it's not a sex scandal."
In other words, the grading of sex as the be all and end all of a pastoral career as sin goes makes us tacitly say "Anything short of a sex scandal is basically not that bad and doesn't disqualify a man from ministry no matter how bad he may be about money, power, ego, deceit, narcissism, or some other character flaw. The main point is that he doesn't make us look too bad." The other things that Breen touches on are things that celebrity pastors that can do that are driven by consumerism or competition.
About consumerism Breen says a few things but I want to consider this ... :
Yet most of our churches are built around feeding consumers. I’d argue 90% of the church’s time, energy and resources are linked to this. But the issue is this: The means you use to attract people to you are usually the means you must use to keep them. In other words, if you use consumerism to attract them to your church, it often means you must continue using it to keep them…or else they will find another church who will meet their “needs.” And yet…that consumer mentality is antithetical to the Gospel and to the call of Discipleship.
Disciples aren’t consumers, they are producers. Jesus cared about disciples more than anything else. Question: In what ways is your church community using consumerism as the means to draw people to a Gospel that is, in and of itself, anti-consumerism?
Ever hear the old saw, "What you win them with is what you win them to?" Now let me play a little game here for the sake of this post. Let me propose that talking people into doing tons of stuff for the local church, getting "plugged in" and making sure you're not merely a consumer is the perfect line for a Pharisee. Why? Because the pursuit of piety can become a paradoxical form of consumerism. The Pharisee does not want to be a "consumer" and wants to be a producer and the various rules devised by Pharisees can help establish what the rules of good spiritual productivity are. David Martyn Lloyd-Jones said about the danger of sin is that it is so pernicious it can travel with us into the very nature of our prayer to the Lord.
If a preacher shills a book saying that if you give X amount to the church you get a book free is that fighting consumerism? Or is it a convenient way of asking for a gift of X or more and giving the book away as a gift to hide the reality that you just BOUGHT SOMETHING. Now if I buy a CD of chamber music for guitar by Castelnuovo-Tedesco I've got no illusion I just bought something. If I give a gift to some ostensibly charitable cause and in return I get a gift the giftis being given me to recognize I have given an unusually large gift and I'm being encouraged to consider giving in the future. I used to work with major donor officers and planned giving staff so it's not like I didn't learn anything about how gifts work in non-profit. The thing is that the gifts are modest and in most respects non-personalized. The gifts are also not things that provide royalties to the officers and staff who sent them out (that's what salaries and hourly wages are for!). But I'm going to save the subject of publishing for another entry.
Now about competition Breen writes, among other things:
... 96% of church growth is due to transfer growth and not churches striking into the heart of our enemy’s territory. We’ll consider it a win because we have the new service or program that is growing…but that growth is mainly from people coming from other churches. That’s not a win! That’s a staggering loss. Furthermore, for many pastors, we don’t think we’ve won until we’ve won AND someone else has lost. Seriously?! For sure, we have an enemy and we should be competitive, but we should be competing against our enemy, knowing that the final battle has already been won, and not competing against our own team members.
So gifted and skilled is our enemy, so conniving is he, that he has convinced us that beating the people on our own team is victory while he stands back and laughs, rarely having to ever engage in conflict, protecting his territory. He is beating us with a slight of hand, with a clever distraction, turning us against ourselves. Question: In what ways are you competing (both in actuality or simply in your mind) against people who are on your own team?
Transfer growth is not a win. The acquisition of an existing church and its members into a network does not constitute a real win for the Gospel. It does not constitute souls being saved, it constitutes a victory for a consumeristic expansion of a religious institution that sees any growth, even transfer growth, as some kind of proof of God's favor.
Of course Christians have a wonderful loophole for this conundrum, that is to decide that on doctrinal grounds a whole bunch of self-identified Christians CAN'T BE TRULY CHRISTIAN. So if you view Catholics as not real Christians and you're a particular brand of Protestant you still win by making Catholics convert to your real brand of Christianity. Same goes in reverse. Same can apply for a super-Calvinist who wins an Arminian over to "the doctrines of grace" or an Arminian who wins a Calvinist over to the "real Jesus". When you make secondary issues, let alone third-rate theological issues (like complementarianism or eschatological schools of thought) primary level issues then you can justify competition within the body of Christ as justified because the people you're competing with are people you've just defined out of fellowship. So that other church has a pastor who doesn't REALLY get the Gospel like your pastor does and that warrants enlisting people to visit your church because your pastor "gets it". Unsurprisingly in many cases this sort of competition emerges from a kind of consumerism.
No comments:
Post a Comment